• Trending
Does Africa have 54, 55 countries… or more?

Does Africa have 54, 55 countries… or more?

August 6, 2021
Why do the two Congos have the same name?

Why do the two Congos have the same name?

1th December 2022
Zelensky

African presidents shun Volodymyr Zelensky

21th June 2022
Sex tourism in Africa, between taboos and instrumentalisation

Sex tourism in Africa, between taboos and instrumentalisation

September 27, 2021
Black Ax

[Gangs of Africa] "Black Axe", the mysterious Nigerian mafia

August 2, 2022
Hassan Morocco

Morocco: the heir Hassan III, the spitting image of his grandfather?

17th February 2022
Africa Elections 2022

2022, year of elections and uncertainties in Africa

2th January 2022
Philip Simo

[Series] The scammers of Africa: Philippe Simo, the "smooth talker" entrepreneur

March 9, 2022
The arming of Ukraine by the Americans goes through Morocco

The arming of Ukraine by the Americans goes through Morocco

6th December 2022
The pen and the sword: Emir Abdelkader

The pen and the sword: Emir Abdelkader

4th May 2021
Francois Beya

DRC: who is François Beya, the "Mister Intelligence" who has just been arrested?

6th February 2022
Where do the best African dates come from?

Where do the best African dates come from?

9th May 2021
Thursday, 21 September 2023
Passports
العربية AR 简体中文 ZH-CN English EN Français FR Deutsch DE Português PT Русский RU Español ES Türkçe TR
Country
No Result
View All Result
The Journal of Africa
canxnumx
Careers
  • Home
  • Africa yesterday
    What economic consequences after the earthquake in Morocco?

    What economic consequences after the earthquake in Morocco?

    Gabon: how the 56-year reign of the Bongo family harmed the country

    Gabon: how the 56-year reign of the Bongo family harmed the country

    920 million people facing river-related conflicts by 2050?

    920 million people facing river-related conflicts by 2050?

    Algeria: Priceless independence

    Algeria: Priceless independence

    Slavery: after the apologies of the Netherlands, reparations?

    Slavery: after the apologies of the Netherlands, reparations?

    Who was Maman Creppy, the queen of textiles and wax ambassador?

    Who was Maman Creppy, the queen of textiles and wax ambassador?

    Sierra Leone: African leaders played a key role in ending the transatlantic slave trade

    Sierra Leone: African leaders played a key role in ending the transatlantic slave trade

    Cameroon: who was John Fru Ndi, the historic opponent of Paul Biya?

    Cameroon: who was John Fru Ndi, the historic opponent of Paul Biya?

    60 years after its creation, what is the African Union still for?

    60 years after its creation, what is the African Union still for?

  • Africa today
    Understanding the coup in Gabon

    Understanding the coup in Gabon

    For a geographical analysis of disasters: the case of the September 8 earthquake in Morocco

    For a geographical analysis of disasters: the case of the September 8 earthquake in Morocco

    Paul RafanoharanaAndry Rajoelina

    Madagascar: the withdrawal of the President of the Senate, an institutional putsch?

    In Gabon, family quarrels or political strategy?

    These reasons which explain the coup d'état in Gabon

    In Morocco, nearly 2 dead after the earthquake

    In Morocco, nearly 2 dead after the earthquake

    Africa-France Summit: Macron and the 40 Burkinabés

    France in Africa: why Macron's policies have increased distrust and anger

    In Niger, French troops about to leave?

    French troops without a fixed military base?

    Between the DRC and Gabon, the end of the diplomatic battle?

    What starting point for Ali Bongo Ondimba?

    When the cocoa boom in Liberia leads to deforestation

    When the cocoa boom in Liberia leads to deforestation

  • Africa according to
    DRC: Denis Mukwege, the electoral asset of Félix Tshisekedi

    In the DRC, is Dr. Mukwege preparing his electoral campaign?

    In 2024, the BRICS will have three African countries

    In 2024, the BRICS will have three African countries

    In South Africa, the BRICS are preparing to shake the world of finance

    In South Africa, the BRICS are preparing to shake the world of finance

    An Earth observation satellite made in Côte d'Ivoire

    An Earth observation satellite made in Côte d'Ivoire

    In Congo-Brazzaville, the orphan opposition

    In Congo-Brazzaville, the orphan opposition

    Winning the World Cup, an inaccessible dream for African teams?

    Finally a World Cup in North Africa?

    The BRICS, towards a new multipolar or Sino-American world order?

    What if the BRICS welcomed European countries?

    African Union: ECOWAS unites, the Maghreb disunited

    Can climate action restore the image of the African Union?

    How the African G4 is trying to develop its agricultural sector

    How Nigeria wants to reduce its dependence on oil exports

  • Editorial
    tonakpa

    [Tonakpa's mood] The new “military democracies”

    [Editorial] 30 years later, is apartheid really over?

    [Editorial] 30 years later, is apartheid really over?

    [Edito] Gabon and Commonwealth: the whims of Prince Ali

    [Edito] Gabon and Commonwealth: the whims of Prince Ali

    [Editorial] Facebook and Twitter, more dictators than dictators?

    [Editorial] Facebook and Twitter, more dictators than dictators?

    [Edito] Rwanda: for the French apologies, we will have to go back

    [Edito] Rwanda: for the French apologies, we will have to go back

    [Edito] Guinea: Alpha Condé, the oppressed turned oppressor

    [Edito] Guinea: Alpha Condé, the oppressed turned oppressor

    [Edito] CFA Franc: a facelift cut to measure for France

    [Edito] CFA Franc: a facelift cut to measure for France

    [Edito] Riyad Mahrez: One, two, three, viva l'Algérie!

    [Edito] Riyad Mahrez: One, two, three, viva l'Algérie!

    [Edito] Niger: Mohamed Bazoum begins a delicate balancing act

    [Edito] Niger: Mohamed Bazoum begins a delicate balancing act

  • Contact
  • Home
  • Africa yesterday
    What economic consequences after the earthquake in Morocco?

    What economic consequences after the earthquake in Morocco?

    Gabon: how the 56-year reign of the Bongo family harmed the country

    Gabon: how the 56-year reign of the Bongo family harmed the country

    920 million people facing river-related conflicts by 2050?

    920 million people facing river-related conflicts by 2050?

    Algeria: Priceless independence

    Algeria: Priceless independence

    Slavery: after the apologies of the Netherlands, reparations?

    Slavery: after the apologies of the Netherlands, reparations?

    Who was Maman Creppy, the queen of textiles and wax ambassador?

    Who was Maman Creppy, the queen of textiles and wax ambassador?

    Sierra Leone: African leaders played a key role in ending the transatlantic slave trade

    Sierra Leone: African leaders played a key role in ending the transatlantic slave trade

    Cameroon: who was John Fru Ndi, the historic opponent of Paul Biya?

    Cameroon: who was John Fru Ndi, the historic opponent of Paul Biya?

    60 years after its creation, what is the African Union still for?

    60 years after its creation, what is the African Union still for?

  • Africa today
    Understanding the coup in Gabon

    Understanding the coup in Gabon

    For a geographical analysis of disasters: the case of the September 8 earthquake in Morocco

    For a geographical analysis of disasters: the case of the September 8 earthquake in Morocco

    Paul RafanoharanaAndry Rajoelina

    Madagascar: the withdrawal of the President of the Senate, an institutional putsch?

    In Gabon, family quarrels or political strategy?

    These reasons which explain the coup d'état in Gabon

    In Morocco, nearly 2 dead after the earthquake

    In Morocco, nearly 2 dead after the earthquake

    Africa-France Summit: Macron and the 40 Burkinabés

    France in Africa: why Macron's policies have increased distrust and anger

    In Niger, French troops about to leave?

    French troops without a fixed military base?

    Between the DRC and Gabon, the end of the diplomatic battle?

    What starting point for Ali Bongo Ondimba?

    When the cocoa boom in Liberia leads to deforestation

    When the cocoa boom in Liberia leads to deforestation

  • Africa according to
    DRC: Denis Mukwege, the electoral asset of Félix Tshisekedi

    In the DRC, is Dr. Mukwege preparing his electoral campaign?

    In 2024, the BRICS will have three African countries

    In 2024, the BRICS will have three African countries

    In South Africa, the BRICS are preparing to shake the world of finance

    In South Africa, the BRICS are preparing to shake the world of finance

    An Earth observation satellite made in Côte d'Ivoire

    An Earth observation satellite made in Côte d'Ivoire

    In Congo-Brazzaville, the orphan opposition

    In Congo-Brazzaville, the orphan opposition

    Winning the World Cup, an inaccessible dream for African teams?

    Finally a World Cup in North Africa?

    The BRICS, towards a new multipolar or Sino-American world order?

    What if the BRICS welcomed European countries?

    African Union: ECOWAS unites, the Maghreb disunited

    Can climate action restore the image of the African Union?

    How the African G4 is trying to develop its agricultural sector

    How Nigeria wants to reduce its dependence on oil exports

  • Editorial
    tonakpa

    [Tonakpa's mood] The new “military democracies”

    [Editorial] 30 years later, is apartheid really over?

    [Editorial] 30 years later, is apartheid really over?

    [Edito] Gabon and Commonwealth: the whims of Prince Ali

    [Edito] Gabon and Commonwealth: the whims of Prince Ali

    [Editorial] Facebook and Twitter, more dictators than dictators?

    [Editorial] Facebook and Twitter, more dictators than dictators?

    [Edito] Rwanda: for the French apologies, we will have to go back

    [Edito] Rwanda: for the French apologies, we will have to go back

    [Edito] Guinea: Alpha Condé, the oppressed turned oppressor

    [Edito] Guinea: Alpha Condé, the oppressed turned oppressor

    [Edito] CFA Franc: a facelift cut to measure for France

    [Edito] CFA Franc: a facelift cut to measure for France

    [Edito] Riyad Mahrez: One, two, three, viva l'Algérie!

    [Edito] Riyad Mahrez: One, two, three, viva l'Algérie!

    [Edito] Niger: Mohamed Bazoum begins a delicate balancing act

    [Edito] Niger: Mohamed Bazoum begins a delicate balancing act

  • Contact
No Result
View All Result
The Journal of Africa
Home Africa today

Bonnesfeuilles: “Going to war in Mali”

Johanna Siméant-Germanos, Florent Pouponneau and Grégory Daho Following Johanna Siméant-Germanos, Florent Pouponneau and Grégory Daho
fr Français▼
X
ar العربيةzh-CN 简体中文en Englishfr Françaisde Deutschla Latinmt Maltesefa فارسیpt Portuguêsru Русскийes Españoltr Türkçe
Wednesday June 8, 2022, at 13:26 am
In Africa today
A A
Bonnesfeuilles: “Going to war in Mali”

Between the fight against terrorism and questions about the sustainability of Françafrique, what legitimacy for French intervention in Mali?

We are publishing an excerpt from the new book by Johanna Siméant-Germanos, Grégory Daho and Florent Pouponneau, teacher-researchers in political science, respectively at the Department of Social Sciences of the ENS, at the Department of Political Sciences of the University of Paris 1 Panthéon Sorbonne , at Sciences Po Strasbourg “Going to war in Mali”, published in the “Social Sciences” Collection of Rue d'Ulm. This passage focuses on the military operation Serval led by the French army in northern Mali in 2013-2014.


French strategy in Africa

Would Serval be just another jolt of Françafrique? In terms of French interventions in Africa, a break marked the mid-1990s. The questioning of France's role in Rwanda, the Balladur doctrine conditioning support for alignment with the criteria of the International Monetary Fund and the World Bank, then the Jospinian doctrine of "neither interference nor indifference", contributed to a return to favor of the discourse evoking the end of Françafrique.

The redeployment of the French strategy which seems to be taking place in Africa, and with a few unilateral exceptions, especially in Ivory Coast in 2002, materializes through the multilateral promotion of numerous cooperation programs aimed at regionalizing the continent's security: Strengthening African Peacekeeping Capacities (RECAMP), Security Sector Reforms (SSR), Disarmament, Demobilization and Reintegration (DDR). If support for regional groupings is the principle around which France today articulates its security diplomacy – like the mobilization of ECOWAS upstream of Operation Serval, the renewed American interest in the continent is manifested by another option: direct support for some pivotal states (South Africa, Ethiopia, Kenya, Uganda, Senegal).

However, it is France, and not the European Union or a UN force, which went to war in Mali. Serval seems to constitute under this aspect a "regionalized unilateralism": if the unilateral implementation of the military intervention is not in doubt (despite, as we will see, the dependence on American means of transport and surveillance and the support on the Chadian troops), its preparation and its legitimation borrow a multilateral register. France's African policy therefore continues to translate into "a interference anointed with the multilateral, UN, African or European Blessed Sacrament in which it never really respects the multilateral and African game that it claims to be playing”.

In other words, the multilateral management of African crises is not incompatible with the unilateral logic inherited from colonial history. France has less abandoned its neocolonial tradition than it has been pushed to do by the retraction of its means and the weakening of its legitimacy. And EU interventions are carried out with a leading country which has every chance of being a former colonial country.

Serval, a combat brigade (Ministry of the Armed Forces, April 29, 2015).

The fight against terrorism

Another peculiarity distinguishes Serval in the history of French interventions in Africa. We are certainly dealing with a lightning operation made possible by the colonial heritage – defense agreements, prepositioned forces, know-how and reciprocal expectations between French and Malian authorities. But Mali was not historically part of the Foccartian pre-square, and the affinities between Malian and French political elites had nothing to do with those which characterized, on the contrary, the Congo, Cameroon, Gabon, Côte d'Ivoire. – even Senegal.

In 1960, Mali had brutally announced its independence, and opted for a socialist path. Considered a State with few natural resources, Mali is a "heavily indebted poor country" (HIPC) of which France remains the 2e official development assistance (ODA) funder. If there was an economic interest in intervening, he first referred to neighboring Niger, a supplier of uranium. Intervention is therefore not simply a matter of the classic game of Françafrique transactions.

The intervention in Mali must therefore be placed in the sequence that began in 2001 in the United States and ten years later in France: the systematization of the “fight against terrorism”. We cannot simply consider this narration as a rhetorical dressing, as its effects are structuring on the legitimization and the enunciation of the ways of waging war, of justifying it and of financing it. In particular, Operation Barkhane, which will follow Serval, is often described on the edge of anti-terrorism and State building.

The legitimacy of Operation Serval

First of all, the political legitimacy of these interventions comes from international mandates even if, strictly speaking, the multilateral justification of French action in Côte d'Ivoire in 2002 or in Mali in 2013 intervenes a posteriori. Then, the legitimization of an intervention depends on the opportunity: in the Malian case, in addition to the "column" materializing the threat, the bad calculations of the "jihadist groups". Thirdly, the intervention requires financial resources burdened by the repayment of public deficits. These resources condition the manpower and the means used (men on the ground, air support, surveillance system, rental of troop transport planes and equipment). Finally, national support constitutes the last level of preparation for an intervention: beyond the involvement of intermediary bodies and other opinion relays (journalists, parliamentarians, industrialists, researchers, etc.), most studies show that this support declines over time.

In other words, the age of the military presence in Africa is only one factor, admittedly a major one, among others in explaining the morphology of a lightning operation (in any case planned as such at its start), at the same such as the regular participation in multilateral post-Cold War interventions, the responsiveness of the decision-making chain or the professional expertise recognized for officers by the political authorities. It is by combining all of these factors that the French authorities have been able to reinforce the multilateral legitimacy of the intervention while maintaining strong operational autonomy in relation to the United Nations.

The anti-terrorist framing of the intervention in Mali contributes to two unintended effects: the search by states by international annuity of the [fight against terrorism], and, on the analytical level, a narrowly securitized reading depoliticizing local issues. However, the history of northern irredentisms, Tuaregs in particular – and their growing articulation with the Sahelian upheavals, shows that rallying to the themes of which the “jihadist” organizations were carriers also refers to the long history of dissatisfactionof their politicization, in northern Mali.

Going to war in Mali, Political and bureaucratic struggles around the French intervention – Grégory Daho, Florent Pouponneau and Johanna Siméant-Germanos.
ENS PSL

Le initial uprising, from the MNLA, run by young people Tuareg educated, rallied by elders returning from Libya, was quickly "overtaken" by "jihadist" organizations, including Ansar Dine, led by Iyad al Ghaly, who took advantage of the destabilization caused to gain the upper hand in the North. The rallying logics varied according to the places of their anchoring and what they offered: the Mujao, for example, essentially recruited in Gao in the early days, relying in particular on an old land dispute between Peuls and Tuaregs, before being rallied by large traders, traffickers and notables of the Lemhar community. We understand that the widespread discourse among some of the officers of the French army of a potential MNLA partner, if it has its own rationality, neglects the particularly complex logic of rallying to the uprisings in the north.


This article is published as part of the symposium “African Modernities. Conversations, circulations, decentrings”, which takes place from June 9 to 11, 2022 at ENS-PSL, on the Jourdan and Ulm campuses. Find the program here of these exchanges.

Johanna Siméant-Germanos, Professor of political science, École normale supérieure (ENS) - PSL; Florent Pouponneau, Lecturer in political science, Sciences Po Strasbourg – University of Strasbourgand Gregory Daho, Lecturer in political science, Paris 1 Panthéon-Sorbonne University

This article is republished from The Conversation under Creative Commons license. Read theoriginal article.

Tags: in onePolicy
Previous Article

Cameroon confesses to crimes against civilians committed by the army

Next article

Rwanda: connectivity in Africa at the center of concerns

Johanna Siméant-Germanos, Florent Pouponneau and Grégory Daho

Johanna Siméant-Germanos, Florent Pouponneau and Grégory Daho

Leave comments Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked with *

All the news About AFLIP
  • South Africa
  • Algeria
  • Angola
  • Benin
  • Botswana
  • Burkina Faso
  • Burundi
  • Cameroon
  • Cabo Verde
  • Central
  • Comoros
  • Ivory Coast
  • Djibouti
  • Egypt
  • Eritrea
  • Ethiopia
  • Gabon
  • The Gambia
  • Ghana
  • Guinea
  • Guinea-Bissau
  • Equatorial Guinea
  • Kenya
  • Lesotho
  • Liberia
  • Libya
  • Madagascar
  • Malawi
  • Mali
  • Morocco
  • Mauritius
  • Mauritania
  • Mozambique
  • Namibia
  • Niger
  • Nigeria
  • Uganda
  • Republic of Congo
  • DR Congo
  • Rwanda
  • Sao Tome and Principe
  • Senegal
  • Seychelles
  • Sierra Leone
  • Somalia
  • Sudan
  • South Sudan
  • Swaziland
  • Tanzania
  • Chad
  • Tunisia
  • Togo
  • Zambia
  • Zimbabwe

Maghreb & Middle East

  • Algeria
  • Egypt
  • Libya
  • Morocco
  • Mauritania
  • Middle-East
  • Tunisia

West Africa

  • Benin
  • Burkina Faso
  • Cabo Verde
  • Ivory Coast
  • The Gambia
  • Ghana
  • Guinea Conakry
  • Guinea-Bissau
  • Liberia
  • Mali
  • Niger
  • Nigeria
  • Senegal
  • Sierra Leone
  • Togo

Central Africa

  • Central African Republic
  • Cameroon
  • Gabon
  • Equatorial Guinea
  • Democratic Republic of Congo
  • Republic of Congo
  • Chad
  • Sao Tome and Principe

East Africa

  • Burundi
  • Djibouti
  • Eritrea
  • Ethiopia
  • Kenya
  • Uganda
  • Rwanda
  • Somalia
  • Sudan
  • South Sudan
  • Tanzania

Southern Africa and Indian Ocean

  • South Africa
  • Angola
  • Botswana
  • Comoros
  • Lesotho
  • Madagascar
  • Malawi
  • Mauritius
  • Mozambique
  • Namibia
  • Seychelles
  • Eswatini
  • Zambia
  • Zimbabwe
  • Who are we ?
  • Editorial
  • Legal notices
  • Contact
  • May 2021
العربية AR 简体中文 ZH-CN English EN Français FR Deutsch DE Português PT Русский RU Español ES Türkçe TR

© 2022 The Journal of Africa.

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Africa according to
  • Africa yesterday
  • Africa today
  • Careers
  • Passports
  • May 2021
  • Contact

© 2022 The Journal of Africa.

Welcome back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Create New Account!

Fill the forms below to register

Đã cần thiết All trường. Log In

Retrieve your password

Hãy nhập tên người dùng hoặc địa chỉ email để mở mật khẩu

Log In

Add new playlist

Go to Mobile Version