• Trending
Zelensky

African presidents shun Volodymyr Zelensky

21th June 2022
Why do the two Congos have the same name?

Why do the two Congos have the same name?

1th December 2022
Does Africa have 54, 55 countries… or more?

Does Africa have 54, 55 countries… or more?

August 6, 2021
Africa Elections 2022

2022, year of elections and uncertainties in Africa

2th January 2022
Sex tourism in Africa, between taboos and instrumentalisation

Sex tourism in Africa, between taboos and instrumentalisation

September 27, 2021
Hassan Morocco

Morocco: the heir Hassan III, the spitting image of his grandfather?

17th February 2022
The arming of Ukraine by the Americans goes through Morocco

The arming of Ukraine by the Americans goes through Morocco

6th December 2022
Francois Beya

DRC: who is François Beya, the "Mister Intelligence" who has just been arrested?

6th February 2022
Black Ax

[Gangs of Africa] "Black Axe", the mysterious Nigerian mafia

August 2, 2022
Elizabeth II

Elizabeth II: a stainless queen and an empire that refuses to die

6th June 2022
Philip Simo

[Series] The scammers of Africa: Philippe Simo, the "smooth talker" entrepreneur

March 9, 2022
Horn of africa

How Chinese and Americans fight over the Horn of Africa

9th January 2022
Wednesday February 8 2023
Passports
العربية AR 简体中文 ZH-CN English EN Français FR Deutsch DE Português PT Русский RU Español ES Türkçe TR
Country
No Result
View All Result
The Journal of Africa
canxnumx
Careers
  • Home
  • Africa yesterday
    Large mammals shaped human evolution: Here's why it happened in Africa

    Large mammals shaped human evolution: Here's why it happened in Africa

    January 26, 1978: the day Tunisia experienced a “Black Thursday”

    January 26, 1978: the day Tunisia experienced a “Black Thursday”

    Rwandan genocidaire Aloys Ntiwiragabo files complaint after being compared to a Nazi

    Rwandan genocidaire Aloys Ntiwiragabo files complaint after being compared to a Nazi

    22 years later, the death of Laurent-Désiré Kabila has not revealed all its secrets

    22 years later, the death of Laurent-Désiré Kabila has not revealed all its secrets

    White Egypt, Black Egypt: The Story of an American Quarrel

    White Egypt, Black Egypt: The Story of an American Quarrel

    Algeria-France: a new start?

    Why does France refuse to ask forgiveness for colonization?

    Who was the Senegalese Ousmane Sembène, the "father of African cinema"?

    Who was the Senegalese Ousmane Sembène, the "father of African cinema"?

    The painful history of North Africa during the Second World War

    The painful history of North Africa during the Second World War

    At the polls (5/7): the Zimbabwe African National Union really unshakable?

    At the polls (5/7): the Zimbabwe African National Union really unshakable?

  • Africa today
    Samuel Eto'o, the defender of African football

    Does Samuel Eto'o have a chance of bending Le Coq Sportif?

    Decline in mass tourism: the transformation of an emblematic seaside resort in Senegal

    Decline in mass tourism: the transformation of an emblematic seaside resort in Senegal

    In Cameroon, the embarrassing Martinez Zogo affair

    In Cameroon, the embarrassing Martinez Zogo affair

    Nigeria: Muhammadu Buhari does not want to think about 2023

    Nigeria: faced with the risk of violence, what responsibility for the outgoing president?

    Contaminated drugs in Gambia: the scandalous Indian denial

    Contaminated drugs in Gambia: the scandalous Indian denial

    Football: Senegal on the roof of Africa

    Football: Senegal on the roof of Africa

    Moody's

    Nigeria, Congo, Tunisia… The diktat of the rating agencies

    Grammy Awards: Angélique Kidjo on track to set a record?

    Grammy Awards: Angélique Kidjo on track to set a record?

    In Senegal, are the hippopotamus doomed to disappear?

    In Senegal, are the hippopotamus doomed to disappear?

  • Africa according to
    Food security in Africa: growing legumes to use less mineral fertilizers?

    Food security in Africa: growing legumes to use less mineral fertilizers?

    George Weah misses his constitutional reform

    In Liberia, George Weah aims for the double

    What prospects for the African economy in 2023?

    What prospects for the African economy in 2023?

    Take inspiration from Asia for the organization of sporting events?

    CAN 2025: who is the favorite to host the competition?

    At the polls (7/7): in Sierra Leone, will Julius Maada Bio remain in office?

    At the polls (7/7): in Sierra Leone, will Julius Maada Bio remain in office?

    DRC: how Tshisekedi wants to take action

    At the polls (6/7): Will Félix Tshisekedi go into extra time?

    At the polls (4/7): in Liberia, George Weah on the sidelines?

    At the polls (4/7): in Liberia, George Weah on the sidelines?

    Muhammadu Buhari

    At the polls (3/7): in Nigeria, who will succeed Muhammadu Buhari?

    Between the DRC and Gabon, the end of the diplomatic battle?

    At the polls (2/7): Ali Bongo Ondimba, a leader without a dolphin

  • Editorial
    tonakpa

    [Tonakpa's mood] The new “military democracies”

    [Editorial] 30 years later, is apartheid really over?

    [Editorial] 30 years later, is apartheid really over?

    [Edito] Gabon and Commonwealth: the whims of Prince Ali

    [Edito] Gabon and Commonwealth: the whims of Prince Ali

    [Editorial] Facebook and Twitter, more dictators than dictators?

    [Editorial] Facebook and Twitter, more dictators than dictators?

    [Edito] Rwanda: for the French apologies, we will have to go back

    [Edito] Rwanda: for the French apologies, we will have to go back

    [Edito] Guinea: Alpha Condé, the oppressed turned oppressor

    [Edito] Guinea: Alpha Condé, the oppressed turned oppressor

    [Edito] CFA Franc: a facelift cut to measure for France

    [Edito] CFA Franc: a facelift cut to measure for France

    [Edito] Riyad Mahrez: One, two, three, viva l'Algérie!

    [Edito] Riyad Mahrez: One, two, three, viva l'Algérie!

    [Edito] Niger: Mohamed Bazoum begins a delicate balancing act

    [Edito] Niger: Mohamed Bazoum begins a delicate balancing act

  • Contact
  • Home
  • Africa yesterday
    Large mammals shaped human evolution: Here's why it happened in Africa

    Large mammals shaped human evolution: Here's why it happened in Africa

    January 26, 1978: the day Tunisia experienced a “Black Thursday”

    January 26, 1978: the day Tunisia experienced a “Black Thursday”

    Rwandan genocidaire Aloys Ntiwiragabo files complaint after being compared to a Nazi

    Rwandan genocidaire Aloys Ntiwiragabo files complaint after being compared to a Nazi

    22 years later, the death of Laurent-Désiré Kabila has not revealed all its secrets

    22 years later, the death of Laurent-Désiré Kabila has not revealed all its secrets

    White Egypt, Black Egypt: The Story of an American Quarrel

    White Egypt, Black Egypt: The Story of an American Quarrel

    Algeria-France: a new start?

    Why does France refuse to ask forgiveness for colonization?

    Who was the Senegalese Ousmane Sembène, the "father of African cinema"?

    Who was the Senegalese Ousmane Sembène, the "father of African cinema"?

    The painful history of North Africa during the Second World War

    The painful history of North Africa during the Second World War

    At the polls (5/7): the Zimbabwe African National Union really unshakable?

    At the polls (5/7): the Zimbabwe African National Union really unshakable?

  • Africa today
    Samuel Eto'o, the defender of African football

    Does Samuel Eto'o have a chance of bending Le Coq Sportif?

    Decline in mass tourism: the transformation of an emblematic seaside resort in Senegal

    Decline in mass tourism: the transformation of an emblematic seaside resort in Senegal

    In Cameroon, the embarrassing Martinez Zogo affair

    In Cameroon, the embarrassing Martinez Zogo affair

    Nigeria: Muhammadu Buhari does not want to think about 2023

    Nigeria: faced with the risk of violence, what responsibility for the outgoing president?

    Contaminated drugs in Gambia: the scandalous Indian denial

    Contaminated drugs in Gambia: the scandalous Indian denial

    Football: Senegal on the roof of Africa

    Football: Senegal on the roof of Africa

    Moody's

    Nigeria, Congo, Tunisia… The diktat of the rating agencies

    Grammy Awards: Angélique Kidjo on track to set a record?

    Grammy Awards: Angélique Kidjo on track to set a record?

    In Senegal, are the hippopotamus doomed to disappear?

    In Senegal, are the hippopotamus doomed to disappear?

  • Africa according to
    Food security in Africa: growing legumes to use less mineral fertilizers?

    Food security in Africa: growing legumes to use less mineral fertilizers?

    George Weah misses his constitutional reform

    In Liberia, George Weah aims for the double

    What prospects for the African economy in 2023?

    What prospects for the African economy in 2023?

    Take inspiration from Asia for the organization of sporting events?

    CAN 2025: who is the favorite to host the competition?

    At the polls (7/7): in Sierra Leone, will Julius Maada Bio remain in office?

    At the polls (7/7): in Sierra Leone, will Julius Maada Bio remain in office?

    DRC: how Tshisekedi wants to take action

    At the polls (6/7): Will Félix Tshisekedi go into extra time?

    At the polls (4/7): in Liberia, George Weah on the sidelines?

    At the polls (4/7): in Liberia, George Weah on the sidelines?

    Muhammadu Buhari

    At the polls (3/7): in Nigeria, who will succeed Muhammadu Buhari?

    Between the DRC and Gabon, the end of the diplomatic battle?

    At the polls (2/7): Ali Bongo Ondimba, a leader without a dolphin

  • Editorial
    tonakpa

    [Tonakpa's mood] The new “military democracies”

    [Editorial] 30 years later, is apartheid really over?

    [Editorial] 30 years later, is apartheid really over?

    [Edito] Gabon and Commonwealth: the whims of Prince Ali

    [Edito] Gabon and Commonwealth: the whims of Prince Ali

    [Editorial] Facebook and Twitter, more dictators than dictators?

    [Editorial] Facebook and Twitter, more dictators than dictators?

    [Edito] Rwanda: for the French apologies, we will have to go back

    [Edito] Rwanda: for the French apologies, we will have to go back

    [Edito] Guinea: Alpha Condé, the oppressed turned oppressor

    [Edito] Guinea: Alpha Condé, the oppressed turned oppressor

    [Edito] CFA Franc: a facelift cut to measure for France

    [Edito] CFA Franc: a facelift cut to measure for France

    [Edito] Riyad Mahrez: One, two, three, viva l'Algérie!

    [Edito] Riyad Mahrez: One, two, three, viva l'Algérie!

    [Edito] Niger: Mohamed Bazoum begins a delicate balancing act

    [Edito] Niger: Mohamed Bazoum begins a delicate balancing act

  • Contact
No Result
View All Result
The Journal of Africa
Home Africa today

Do Europeans see African “migrants” as strangers to humanity?

Daniel Derivois By Daniel Derivois
fr Français▼
X
ar العربيةzh-CN 简体中文en Englishfr Françaisde Deutschla Latinmt Maltesefa فارسیpt Portuguêsru Русскийes Españoltr Türkçe
Thursday July 21, 2022, at 10:47 PM
Dance Africa today
A A
Do Europeans see African “migrants” as strangers to humanity?

The term "migrant" conveys the remains of a colonial anthropology which sometimes refers to the category of slave or that of dangerous foreigner, writes the professor of clinical psychology Daniel Derivois.

The media and political discourses concerning those who are called "Unaccompanied minors" lead to questions about the place that they occupy in the collective imagination. The traumatic experience of Mo Farah, quadruple Olympic champion in athletics under the British banner, who tells in a documentary broadcast by the BBC on July 13 how it arrived illegally and underage in the UK illustrates this point.

The question deserves to be asked in a XXIe century in which the figure of the "migrant" is the subject of many projections in the host societies. It is all the more crucial as these young people – “without a legal representative” in the host country – are sometimes perceived as an external threat, sometimes as individuals with no history who need to be civilized and assimilated. They are sometimes used as cheap labor to exploit in the form of modern slavery.

Study the “others”

When, in the nineteenthe century, Western epistemology was confronted with the need to study the "others", two major disciplines had emerged: Orientalism to study the "Great Civilizations" and Anthropology to study the cultures of subjugated and oppressed peoples.

This anthropology – historically prior to “symmetrical anthropology” ou "reciprocal" – which would serve and reinforce racial, slavery and colonialist ideologies, notably made an "other" “inferior”, amputated of his humanity. Over time, this “other” will be embodied by several figures, in particular that of “migrant” in the XNUMXst century.e century. The term migrant, as we understand it in the prevailing Western imagination, covers above all the nationals of peoples formerly colonized by western host societies.

A German, English or American “migrant” in France is not perceived in the same way as a Senegalese, Syrian or Algerian “migrant”, for example. A "Westerner" who migrates to a "Southern country" is not designated as a "migrant", but as an "expatriate". In short, the choice of words conveys implicit signifieds which determine the relations between the peoples of the world.

Thus, if we assume that the signifier "migrant" conveys the remains of a colonial anthropology, a reflection is necessary on the signifieds "slave" and "foreigner" with which this signifier can resonate.

A familiar, non-threatening figure

If the "migrant" refers to a slave, it is probably a become familiar. In the past, certain slave societies made a slave whoever was foreign to their territory, but from the moment he had become a slave, he left the status of foreigner to become a familiar. "The characteristic of the slave is his character of exteriority to kinship, which allows his domestication, his familiarity, including his fictitious assimilation to the family like other dependents of the head of the family (children, single women, etc.), even the maintenance of emotional relationships, which will never endanger the established social order. The slave can willingly be the object of an attachment, as long as this is not the threat of a social transgression ". Domesticated, the slave can then serve as easy labour. He is still dehumanized, but is no longer seen as an identity threat.

Today, in our host societies, some bosses have attitudes or behavior towards migrant minors that seem fall under the legacy of slavery. As these young people are in precarious conditions (without papers, psychological distress, etc.), they constitute for them labor that is easy to exploit to the detriment of respect for labor rights.

In an establishment that welcomes unaccompanied minors in a region of France, the educational teams report the case of a young person who works 7 days a week, from 7 a.m. to 7 p.m., without a break and without a pay slip. This young man is convinced that he has every chance on his side to “obtain papers”. “Come and work for free 19 Saturdays a month, said another boss to another young person from this same establishment, and I will give you a certificate for the prefecture”. Another bakery boss goes so far as to threaten a young person to call the prefecture or his school if he does not accept the working conditions. We can also cite these young undocumented migrants to whom delivery people (home meal delivery) sublet their account.

Many young people agree to work under these conditions in order to have a privileged link with an adult (parental figure), a professional activity, a savings, and when possible pay slips that can fill out their files to obtain a residence permit at their majority. These young people are thus caught between their motivations and working conditions. Their status as adolescents or young people is obscured by the condition of a migrant-slave who has become familiar.

A fantasy danger

If, in the imagination, the "migrant" refers more to a foreigner, it is fantasmatically an enemy, someone potentially dangerous, even a terrorist, who comes from outside, and to be wary of. Indeed :

“The slave does not have the same role as the foreigner who would be the object of xenophobia, rejection or structural aggressiveness. For, at the same time as he is symbolically and definitively excluded, the slave is also the familiar, the servant, who we know, like the dog, will remain in the place assigned to him. »

The foreigner is the subject of many fantasies. Sometimes serving as a scapegoat for a society struggling to think about its cohesion or "its disturbing strangeness", it feeds all the amalgams to the point of passing off minors in danger to be protected as dangerous minors to be excluded from the community of men.

The passage, with the Act of March 14 2016 (Law No. 2016-297), from the expression "unaccompanied foreign minor" to that of "unaccompanied minor" thus requires deep reflection on the potential meanings conveyed behind these expressions used to designate these young migrant children and adolescents in our globalized societies. Is it enough to change the word to change the place assigned to them in societal and institutional fantasy?

To what, then, could the term refer in the Western collective unconscious migrant ? When we see the exploitation of certain young people by certain bosses in the host society, when we see the way certain young people are sold at auction in Libya or are exploited in pimping networks in the societies of departure, transit and welcome, it is necessary to put to work the hypothesis according to which they would represent in the collective imagination a slave.

When we see that in the context of the multiple health, social, economic and security crisis, certain media and politicians are pointing the finger at "unaccompanied minors" as potential terrorists, it is necessary to put to work the hypothesis according to which they would represent dangerous outsiders in part of the collective psyche of the host societies.

These two hypotheses (the migrant as a domesticated slave and the migrant as a dangerous stranger) deserve to be tested in social work and in society in general. Their elaboration can lead to a better positioning in relational and transferential dynamics. In any case, whether they are perceived as easy labor slaves or as dangerous foreigners, there is a hiatus in the genealogy of Man. It's as if there were two parts of Humanity that couldn't come together. A humanity cut off from a part of itself. To perceive the migrant as a stranger to Humanity is not to consider him as belonging to the great human family. To perceive him and to treat him as a slave is just as much to deprive him of his humanity. But you have to be dehumanized enough to in turn dehumanize another human being.

In its historical essay on racial order, A. Michel has shown how Europeans had difficulty recognizing a relationship between slaves and themselves. This element says a lot about the difficulty of host societies (States, professionals, citizens or others) in welcoming young migrants as their fellow human beings, and entitled to the same rights as all human beings. It also says a lot about the difficulty some child protection professionals have in seeing young people as mere adolescents who could be their children, brothers, sisters, nephews or nieces. Could this be due to the implication of a slave and a stranger to our common humanity which function “off” in the term “unaccompanied minor”?

As the Nobel Prize for Literature says Toni Morrison, “There are no foreigners. There are only versions of ourselves, many of which we haven't bought into and most of which we want to protect ourselves from”.

We must then ask ourselves why we continue to call them "unaccompanied minors" even though we say we are beginning to accompany them, once their minority has been assessed and admitted into the child protection system. We must ask ourselves about the legacy of colonial anthropology in our gaze on these young people. Faced with the violence of this designation, which contradicts the support mission, shouldn't we call them “newly accompanied minors”?


Daniel Derivois, Professor of Clinical Psychology and Psychopathology. Psy-DREPI laboratory (EA 7458), University of Burgundy - UBFC

This article is republished from The Conversation under Creative Commons license. Read theoriginal article.

Tags: in oneCompany
Previous Article

Distraught Togo, between terrorism and military blunders

Next article

In Tanzania, Samia Suluhu Hassan, an effective and popular president

Daniel Derivois

Daniel Derivois

Leave comments Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked with *

All the news About AFLIP
  • South Africa
  • Algeria
  • Angola
  • Benin
  • Botswana
  • Burkina Faso
  • Burundi
  • Cameroon
  • Green cap
  • Central
  • Comoros
  • Ivory Coast
  • Djibouti
  • Egypt
  • Eritrea
  • Ethiopia
  • Gabon
  • The Gambia
  • Ghana
  • Guinea
  • Guinea-Bissau
  • Equatorial Guinea
  • Kenya
  • Lesotho
  • Liberia
  • Libya
  • Madagascar
  • Malawi
  • Mali
  • Morocco
  • Mauritius
  • Mauritania
  • Mozambique
  • Namibia
  • Niger
  • Nigeria
  • Uganda
  • Republic of Congo
  • DR Congo
  • Rwanda
  • Sao Tome and Principe
  • Senegal
  • Seychelles
  • Sierra Leone
  • Somalia
  • Sudan
  • South Sudan
  • Swaziland
  • Tanzania
  • Chad
  • Tunisia
  • Togo
  • Zambia
  • Zimbabwe

Maghreb & Middle East

  • Algeria
  • Egypt
  • Libya
  • Morocco
  • Mauritania
  • Middle-East
  • Tunisia

West Africa

  • Benin
  • Burkina Faso
  • Green cap
  • Côte d'Ivoire
  • The Gambia
  • Ghana
  • Guinea Conakry
  • Guinea-Bissau
  • Liberia
  • Mali
  • Niger
  • Nigeria
  • Senegal
  • Sierra Leone
  • Togo

Central Africa

  • Central African Republic
  • Cameroon
  • Gabon
  • Equatorial Guinea
  • Democratic Republic of Congo
  • Republic of Congo
  • Chad
  • Sao Tome and Principe

East Africa

  • Burundi
  • Djibouti
  • Eritrea
  • Ethiopia
  • Kenya
  • Uganda
  • Rwanda
  • Somalia
  • Sudan
  • South Sudan
  • Tanzania

Southern Africa and Indian Ocean

  • South Africa
  • Angola
  • Botswana
  • Comoros
  • Lesotho
  • Madagascar
  • Malawi
  • Mauritius
  • Mozambique
  • Namibia
  • Seychelles
  • Eswatini
  • Zambia
  • Zimbabwe
  • About us
  • Editorial
  • Legal notices
  • Contact
  • May 2021
العربية AR 简体中文 ZH-CN English EN Français FR Deutsch DE Português PT Русский RU Español ES Türkçe TR

© 2022 The Journal of Africa.

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Africa according to
  • Africa yesterday
  • Africa today
  • Careers
  • Passports
  • May 2021
  • Contact

© 2022 The Journal of Africa.

Welcome back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Create New Account!

Fill the forms below to register

Đã cần thiết All trường. Log In

Retrieve your password

Hãy nhập tên người dùng hoặc địa chỉ email để mở mật khẩu

Log In

Add new playlist

Go to Mobile Version